The COYU method and Bennett method. The empirical comparison of decisions concerning uniformity of crop plants cultivars
Bogna Zawieja
bogna.zawieja@up.poznan.plKatedra Metod Matematycznych i Statystycznych, Uniwersytet Przyrodniczy, Poznań (Poland)
Wiesław Pilarczyk
Katedra Metod Matematycznych i Statystycznych, Uniwersytet Przyrodniczy, Poznań (Poland)
Bogna Kowalczyk
Centralny Ośrodek Badania Odmian Roślin Uprawnych, Słupia Wielka (Poland)
Abstract
Before registration, each new variety of crop plants, has to be tested in terms of its uniformity. The decisions concerning uniformity of new varieties („candidates”) are taken for all tested characteristics, both quantitative and qualitative. In the case of qualitative characteristics, in the sample of fixed size, the number of non-typical plants is observed and if the fraction of such plants exceeds some threshold, this variety is considered as not fulfilling the condition of uniformity. In the case of quantitative characteristics the procedure is more complicated. The standard deviation of the candidate variety and average of standard deviations of registered varieties (sown in the same trial) is compared. The officially recommended method, in countries associated in UPOV organization, is so called the COYU procedure. This method is computationally complicated. Study of the homogeneity of variation coefficients is a much easier method, then the Bennett’s method can be used. A new method can be introduced to research methodology only when results obtained with new method are similar to the results of the previous one. Therefore, in this study, all the obtained results of comparison of both methods are summarized . These methods, in general, are consistent (in some of examples the COYU method was more restrictive, while in others it was the Bennett’s method, but these differences, usually, were not statistically significant).
Keywords:
Bennett’s method, COYU methods, OWT researches, simulation, uniformity of varieties, winter oil rapeReferences
Bennett B. M. 1976. On an approximate test for homogeneity of coefficients of variation. In: Contributions to applied statistics (ed. W.I. Ziegler). Birkhäuser Verlag: 169 — 171.
Google Scholar
Forkman J. 2006. Statistical inference for the coefficient of variation in normally distributed data. Research Report 2006: 2, Centre of Biostochatics Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences.
Google Scholar
Iglewicz B. and Meyers R. H. 1970. Comparison of approximations of the percentage points of the sample coefficient of variation. Technometrics 12: 166 — 169.
Google Scholar
Iglewicz B., Meyers R. H., Howe R. B. 1968. On the percentage points of the sample coefficient of variation. Biometrika 56: 580 — 581.
Google Scholar
Kendall M. G., Buckland W. R. 1986. Słownik terminów statystycznych. PWE, Warszawa.
Google Scholar
Kristensen K., Roberts A. 2009. Potential approaches to improving COYU. UPOV Geneva. TWC/27/15: 1 — 8.
Google Scholar
McKay A. T. 1932. Distribution of the coefficient of variation and the extender distribution. J.R. Statist. Sec. 95: 695 — 698.
Google Scholar
McNemar Q. 1947. Note on the sampling error of the difference between correlated proportions or percentages. Psychometrika 12: 153 — 157.
Google Scholar
Pilarczyk W., Zawieja B. 2006. The comparison of decisions on uniformity of rye varieties based on COYU approach and Bennett’s test. Colloquium Biometricum 36: 225 — 233.
Google Scholar
Rudas T. 1998. Odds Ratios in the Analysis of Contingency Tables. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publ.
Google Scholar
Tabolt M. 2000. The Combined-Over-Years Distinctness and Uniformity criteria. UPOV, TWC/18/10, Genewa.
Google Scholar
Uebersax J. 2006. Odds Ratio and Yule's Q. http://www.john-uebersax.com/stat/odds.htm.
Google Scholar
Weatherup S. T. C. 1992. Distinctness, uniformity and stability trial (DUST) analysis system. User manual. Department of Agriculture for Northern Ireland biometrics division. Belfast BT9 5PX.
Google Scholar
Zawieja B., Pilarczyk W. 2005. The comparison of traditional UPOV uniformity criterion and new approach based on Bennett’s test for coefficients of variation. Colloquium Biometricum 35: 155 — 163.
Google Scholar
Zawieja B., Pilarczyk W. 2007. Further comparison of decisions concerning uniformity of rye varieties based on COYU approach and on Bennett’s test. Colloquium Biometricum 37: 71 — 76
Google Scholar
Zawieja B., Pilarczyk W., Kowalczyk B. 2009. The comparison of uniformity decisions based on COYU and Bennett’s method — oilseed rape data. Colloquium Biometricum 39: 170 — 176.
Google Scholar
Zawieja B., Pilarczyk W., Kowalczyk B. 2010. Comparison of uniformity decisions based on COYU and Bennett’s methods — simulated data. Colloquium Biometricum 40: 53 — 61
Google Scholar
Authors
Bogna Zawiejabogna.zawieja@up.poznan.pl
Katedra Metod Matematycznych i Statystycznych, Uniwersytet Przyrodniczy, Poznań Poland
Authors
Wiesław PilarczykKatedra Metod Matematycznych i Statystycznych, Uniwersytet Przyrodniczy, Poznań Poland
Authors
Bogna KowalczykCentralny Ośrodek Badania Odmian Roślin Uprawnych, Słupia Wielka Poland
Statistics
Abstract views: 42PDF downloads: 44
License
Copyright (c) 2012 Bogna Zawieja, Wiesław Pilarczyk, Bogna Kowalczyk
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
Upon submitting the article, the Authors grant the Publisher a non-exclusive and free license to use the article for an indefinite period of time throughout the world in the following fields of use:
- Production and reproduction of copies of the article using a specific technique, including printing and digital technology.
- Placing on the market, lending or renting the original or copies of the article.
- Public performance, exhibition, display, reproduction, broadcasting and re-broadcasting, as well as making the article publicly available in such a way that everyone can access it at a place and time of their choice.
- Including the article in a collective work.
- Uploading an article in electronic form to electronic platforms or otherwise introducing an article in electronic form to the Internet or other network.
- Dissemination of the article in electronic form on the Internet or other network, in collective work as well as independently.
- Making the article available in an electronic version in such a way that everyone can access it at a place and time of their choice, in particular via the Internet.
Authors by sending a request for publication:
- They consent to the publication of the article in the journal,
- They agree to give the publication a DOI (Digital Object Identifier),
- They undertake to comply with the publishing house's code of ethics in accordance with the guidelines of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), (http://ihar.edu.pl/biblioteka_i_wydawnictwa.php),
- They consent to the articles being made available in electronic form under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license, in open access,
- They agree to send article metadata to commercial and non-commercial journal indexing databases.
Most read articles by the same author(s)
- Katarzyna Ambroży, Ewa Bakinowska, Jan Bocianowski, Anna Budka, Wiesław Pilarczyk, Bogna Zawieja, Statistical support of selection decisions at early stage of cereal breeding. Part II. Empirical comparison of treatment effects estimation methods , Bulletin of Plant Breeding and Acclimatization Institute: No. 250 (2008): Regular issue
- Katarzyna Ambroży, Ewa Bakinowska, Jan Bocianowski, Anna Budka, Wiesław Pilarczyk, Bogna Zawieja, Statistical support of selection decisions at early stage of cereal breeding. Part I. Methods of estimation of treatment effects , Bulletin of Plant Breeding and Acclimatization Institute: No. 250 (2008): Regular issue
- Jakub Paderewski, Wiesław Mądry, Wiesław Pilarczyk, Tadeusz Drzazga, Retrospective study of yield response to environmental conditions in winter wheat cultivars using combined AMMI and cluster analysis to incomplete data: genetic progress for adaptability , Bulletin of Plant Breeding and Acclimatization Institute: No. 250 (2008): Regular issue
- Anita Dobek, Jan Bocianowski, Ewa Bakinowska, Wiesław Pilarczyk, Wojciech Mikulski, Jacek Kaczmarek, Problems related to testing of cereal lines at early stages of plant breeding , Bulletin of Plant Breeding and Acclimatization Institute: No. 249 (2008): Regular issue
- Wiesław Pilarczyk, Anna Fraś, Choosing representative subset of locations in series of winter wheat trials , Bulletin of Plant Breeding and Acclimatization Institute: No. 246 (2007): Regular issue
- Bogna Zawieja, Andrzej Bichoński, The selection of breeding lines of spring barley on the basis of statistical analysis of three year trial series , Bulletin of Plant Breeding and Acclimatization Institute: No. 275 (2015): Regular issue
- Wiesław Pilarczyk, Ewa Bakinowska, Jan Bocianowski, Bogna Zawieja, Optimization of preliminary plant breeding trials with spring barley , Bulletin of Plant Breeding and Acclimatization Institute: No. 255 (2010): Regular issue
- Ewa Bakinowska, Jan Bocianowski, Anna Budka, Wiesław Pilarczyk, Bogna Zawieja, Katarzyna Ambroży, Estimation of error variance in unreplicated plant breeding trials with replicated standard treatments , Bulletin of Plant Breeding and Acclimatization Institute: No. 251 (2009): Regular issue
- Wiesław Pilarczyk, Anna Fraś, Estimation of the exactness of cereal variety testing program in Poland , Bulletin of Plant Breeding and Acclimatization Institute: No. 249 (2008): Regular issue
- Bogna Zawieja, Ewa Bakinowska, Wiesław Pilarczyk, The comparison of three methods of selection of best genotypes in unreplicated plant breeding trials , Bulletin of Plant Breeding and Acclimatization Institute: No. 255 (2010): Regular issue
